Collaboration can be hard to define
Friday, 20th April 2012
By James Mullan
What does collaboration mean to you? Does it mean sharing documents with colleagues and collaborating on them? Collaboration should be about people working together to develop a common approach to situations and devising tactics and strategies that help them move forward.
What does collaboration mean to you? Does it mean sharing documents with colleagues and collaborating on them? If so you might want to rethink your definition of collaboration after reviewing the blog post "Sharing files isn't collaboration" by Jack Vinson.
In his post Jack argues that exchanging files and data is not collaboration. In his words " It's simply exchanging files and data". So what does collaboration look like in a typical organisation? Jack argues that collaboration should be about people working together to develop a common approach to situations and devising tactics and strategies that help them move forward. Beyond collaboration is the idea of creating a social business. A social business is one in which people (employees) are at the heart of everything the business does and the tools provided by the business allow employees to get more done. For a more detailed discussion about what social business is and why, for now, it's potentially failing to deliver on its promise, I recommend reading the first resource listed below.
So how should or could collaboration be defined? One of the first issues is trying to identify which tools are and which tools aren't, collaborative. For example a lot of people will say that instant messaging, email, and web conferencing tools aren't collaboration technologies. People will argue that these are communication tools and for the most part they're great at what they do. Naturally you could argue that email and instant messaging tools are becoming more collaborative, especially where they integrate with tools like SharePoint 2010 or where they allow individuals to share content with each other.These tools definitely have a part to play in the collaborative process, but many would argue it's a limited role.
One of the other problems with trying to define collaboration is that it will mean different things to different people. I could be said to be collaborating with someone if I was to write an article with them. Someone else might say they're collaborating by using a tool like Dropbox or GoogleDocs to upload a document and then allow other people to edit it. Collaboration will also mean different things dependent on the size of the organisation an individual works for.
For example, in a small organisation collaboration might mean a few individuals using a tool like Yammer or Confluence to work more effectively with their colleagues by having a tool that allows them to create and share content easily. Whereas in a larger organisation collaboration might mean a project team, department or working group creating a SharePoint site, in which they publish documents, create blogs and wikis, update their status and, for want of a better word, collaborate.
Up to now I've only talked about technology, but, for many, collaboration is about an individual deciding that they want to work with someone else. In fact, search Wikipedia for the term collaboration and you won't find a mention of the word technology. So is collaboration as Michael Sampson puts it a "human behaviour"? Certainly collaboration seems for the most part to be situations where people work together in a particular way towards a common outcome potentially using a collaborative tool to assist them.
When it comes to collaboration context, it would seem, does matter and trying to define what it really means can be hard. But as information professionals it's important to be aware of some of the issues around how we collaborate with each other and the tools that are available. If you're interested in learning more about information sharing, collaboration and how you can approach this subject then the resources listed below should help you do so.
- Blog post title: Collaboration can be hard to define
- Link to this page
- View printable version
- Intranet management strategies and resources
Tuesday, 10th April 2012
- Space shuttles and parrots: Providing incentives for collaboration and knowledge sharing
Tuesday, 20th March 2012
- SharePoint 2010 do's and don'ts
Tuesday, 21st February 2012
- SharePoint and the law firm intranet [ABSTRACT]
Sunday, 31st July 2011
- SharePoint and the South Bank Centre: using analogies to sell a story [ABSTRACT]
Tuesday, 1st March 2011
- SharePoint - Face your fear and do it anyway: Part 1 [ABSTRACT]
Wednesday, 2nd February 2011
- Distance learning as a collaborative enterprise: Tips on teamwork to make the class work
Wednesday, 31st May 2006
Improve your negotiation position, measure performance of your portfolio of external content, and communicate more effectively with stakeholders.
A Jinfo Subscription gets you access to activity-based content to move your projects forward, plus dynamic peer group discussions on meaty topics.
- Research update - aspiring to “strategic”? You’re in good company
Thursday, 18th February 2021
- Research update - assess your strategic portfolio management needs
Thursday, 4th February 2021
- Become a more strategic content portfolio manager
Thursday, 28th January 2021
- Dashboard and collaboration (use-case - intelligence)
Wednesday, 17th February 2021
- Comparison of content management features (use-case - intelligence)
Tuesday, 16th February 2021
- Mini review of Global Market Model
Tuesday, 2nd February 2021
- Community deck - State of the industry, 2021
Wednesday, 24th February 2021
- Product review of Aurora's FirstLight
Monday, 11th January 2021
- Market landscape - patent products
Monday, 21st December 2020
- Negotiation clinic - role-play and Q&A (Community) Tuesday, 13th April 2021
- Usage data in contract negotiations (Community) Tuesday, 23rd March 2021
- Pricing models for information and data licensing (Community) Tuesday, 2nd March 2021
- Comparative product evaluation - breaking it down into manageable pieces (Webinar) Tuesday, 19th January 2021
- The importance of current awareness tracking (Webinar) Tuesday, 12th January 2021
- State of the Industry, 2021 (Webinar) Tuesday, 5th January 2021
Our proven processes, resources and guidance will help your team make the shift from transaction centre to strategic asset.
Designed around the most common challenges and pain points for time- and resource-strapped information teams
A tailored overview of our research and active discussion with your Jinfo analyst.
Measure your starting point to articulate your strengths and set priorities for future improvements. Assessments gauge risk, capacity, value and more.
Read case studies, and start the conversation: